Batman is Dead. Long Live Batman

Monday, December 1st, 2008 at 1:18 pm by Jami

Batman RIP

The big gigantic news of last week was not the culling of mass turkeys nor the insanity of Friday’s Blackened shopping madness. For us, the big, ball busting news of last week was that Bruce Wayne, after years of fighting his inner demons and the demons that plague Gotham City, finally met his end at the hands of Simon Hurt.

Now while the mainstream news will latch on to the bit of dialog where Hurt proclaims that he is Thomas Wayne, those of us who actually read comics know better. Hurt is more likely the Devil himself, the impetus for Bruce’s crusade, the figurative father of Batman.

The question of Dr. Hurt’s true identity, Thomas Wayne or the Devil, is somewhat immaterial. The bigger question is, can there be a Batman without Bruce Wayne?

Will the New Batman Please Stand Up!

We do have ample evidence of the dangers of handing over the mantle of the Bat. Jean-Paul Valley demonstrated his ineptness as a master detective during the whole Knightfall era. Of course, Valley was nucking futs, although let’s face it, a man who dresses up as a flying fuck rat is pretty crazy to begin with anyway. The mantle must be passed on. Batman is more a symbol, a force of nature, than an actual man. But it must be passed on to someone who can walk that delicate balance between madness and sanity. So who should inherit the cape and cowl?

Dick Grayson is the obvious choice. And he did actually step in for a time as Batman after Valley got his ass beat. But I think Blüdhaven needs Nightwing as much as Gotham needs Batman. Tim Drake would be a good choice. He certainly has the detective skills and is possibly more level headed than anyone else in the Bat family. Jason Todd should NEVER get near a Batman costume and should probably be locked up somewhere. Damien? No. Never. For me, it’s between Dick and Tim.

Dead? Comic Book Dead or Dead Dead?

After 70 years of the goddamn Batman, I’m open to change. Unlike Spider-Man’s One Fucked-Up Day, the ending to RIP seems less forced than other comic deaths. No stupid magic spell that rewrites the entire fucking character in an instant. No Son of Your Mother’s Crisis on umpteen Earths. Just a set of completely insane circumstances that proved too much even for the caped crusader.

I’m as much a continuity whore as the next comic geek. I like my Peter Parker married and my Wolverine with adamantium. But for comics to remain relevant, there must be room for growth. Scott should be able to date Emma. Hulk should be able to turn Red or Grey or Green or Heather Yellow.

The mantle of the Bat should be passed on.

10 Responses to “Batman is Dead. Long Live Batman”

  1. AvatarKiey
    1

    In my opinion Cassandra Cain should be Batman, and I feel like that was they way they were taking her character, until they utterly screwed her over (and I think to not let her be was the reason she got screwed over.)

    Regardless I think she is the best choice since, she is a better fighter then Batman ever was, she might not have all the detectiving down but that’s learnable or supportable by other characters. But most importantly she understands Batman’s whole sanctity of life thing (at least she did…) it wasn’t something Bruce had to explain to her, like he had to with the others, she already came to him knowing it.

  2. AvatarJami
    2
    Author Comment

    Oh yeah! I totally forgot about Cassy! With Oracle backing her up, she’d make an imposing Batman. Hell, she’s fucking beast as Batgirl.

  3. AvatarHawk
    3

    I wonder how they’re going to explain “Bruce Wayne” disappearance.

    I’m sorry but I’m not liking this at all. You can’t have Batman without Bruce Wayne.

  4. AvatarJami
    4
    Author Comment

    Well, the helicopter crash over a giant body of water is the easiest comic death to recover from. So I imagine if enough people are pissed, we’ll have Bruce back by the end of next year.

  5. AvatarTaellosse
    5

    Eh, it won’t last. They haven’t got the guts to keep an icon like Batman dead. I don’t follow comics directly anymore, but from what I’ve heard, it’s not even definitive that he’s dead, or even that he’s truly quit the superhero biz.

  6. AvatarMike
    6

    I’ll admit, I kinda like the idea of Cassy being Batman. (Batwoman?) Since Bludhaven needs Nightwing, I guess Drake is the best default. But for me, I love a good shocker ending. Why does it have to be an established member of the Bat family? Why does it even have to be an established DC character? Completely eff with everyone by pulling off something completely off the wall! With the right writer and the right exectuion, this could be a killer reveal, regardless of who’s under the cape and cowl.

  7. AvatarDevin
    7

    Good post, Jam!

    I wonder if they’ll pull a Major League Baseball kinda maneuver and call up Grayson to be the new Bat and send Drake to the minors in Bludhaven to take over there…

    And call me crazy but I wonder if this is DC’s response to the hype and press Marvel received by killing off Captain America, like maybe they were looking for a way to boost hype themselves? The timing seems to fit, as comic scripts are written, what, 6 to 8 months in advance? And since they couldn’t just off Batman right away without serious planning, add in a couple more months to the total to plot out the whole thing and… voila…?

    Or is this just a crazy conspiracy theory?

  8. AvatarLurklen
    8

    Sad as i am to see Bruce go, I’m glad this happend it always botherd me when I was a kid that none of the super heroes I read about ever got older really or that they ever got in real danger. I always knew they were gonna make it, and that got old pretty fast I like the direction mainstream comics is heading it makes things so much more exciting.

  9. Avatarraize
    9

    When we talk about continuity in comics, we should also think abotu the comics themselves. Cultural icons like batman with more than enough room for excellent stories, and tons of material to work with don’t necessarily need to be changed or moved on from. The focal point of the comic, is Batman himself. The one constant is the Dark Knight. Having him as the one constant in his crazy world is what allows them to build the stories (some so great) that they did. He doesn’t need to change, and even if he does die, nothing says that can’t be the end of the legend, while still continuing to write great stories that may have taken place before his death.

    It’s funny, but knowing that Batman is dead doesn’t actually surprise or bother me because ultimately that’s where the character feels like he should end up. Dead. He is more human than most super heroes. If they were ablle to actually come up with an decent end to the character, good for them (I haven’t read any of it yet so I won’t comment on the story itself). Maybe instead of replacing the character they can just tell stories that haven’t been told that occured before his death. I always lliked the self-contained graphic novels the best anyway.

  10. AvatarKunoichi
    10

    But that doesn’t fix the inherent problem of American comics, raize. They never achieve real depth, and they never evolve beyond what they started as. Oh they’ve gotten a bit better, but given the depth they’ve gotten to after how long? 80 years? 90? It’s pathetic compared to Asian comics, especially if we only consider them once they became similar enough to the Western ones for proper comparison, which was only 50 years ago.

    Instead of telling stories about the same people over and over, American comic book writers should be trying to tell completely new stories, about new people. This constant story-telling without a set plan or background of the same characters is how we end up with Wolverine and Spidey’s and a host of others’ stories being so fucked up you have to add in parallel universes, time travel, and hallucinations to make it all work.

    Batman was one of my favorites, because all he had going for him was smarts, science, and insanity. But my favorite storyline in the Batverse? The Batman Beyond t.v. show. Bruce Wayne was a crotchety old man who had to give up the mantle but didn’t want to, and had to groom someone as wild as he was to take it on. They achieved a perfect comprise for American comics: they got to keep their iconic hero but start telling new stories about a new person.

Close
E-mail It